Creamy Catsup

One gallon of the creamiest catsup in all the land.
List price: ₡81.
Made from a Honey, a Red and a King of Condiments using a Saucepan.
A long time ago in an imagination far, far away: Made from a Honey, five Tomatoes, a Pinch of Salt and a Butterfly Milk using a Saucepan.
Is an ingredient for these items: